I Tested the Best Earrings for New Pierced Ears: My Top Picks for Comfort and Style

I remember the excitement and nerves that came with getting my first ear piercing. As I sat in the chair, I couldn’t wait to choose my first pair of earrings. But once the initial thrill wore off, I was left with a throbbing pain and a daunting task of finding the perfect earrings for my new pierced ears. If you’re in the same boat, fear not! After years of trial and error, I have discovered the best earrings for new pierced ears that are not only stylish but also help in healing and preventing any irritation. So, let me be your guide as we explore the world of earrings for new piercings.

I Tested The Best Earrings For New Pierced Ears Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

PAVOI 14K White Gold Plated Post Cubic Zirconia Cuff Earring Huggie Stud

PRODUCT NAME

PAVOI 14K White Gold Plated Post Cubic Zirconia Cuff Earring Huggie Stud

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Claire's 16 Fl Oz Aftercare Ear Piercing Cleaner Solution – Designed to Avoid Infections on Pierced Ears, Nose Piercings, and Belly Button Piercings – Ideal Hole Cleaner for Piercings

PRODUCT NAME

Claire’s 16 Fl Oz Aftercare Ear Piercing Cleaner Solution – Designed to Avoid Infections on Pierced Ears, Nose Piercings, and Belly Button Piercings – Ideal Hole Cleaner for Piercings

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Hypoallergenic Titanium 4mm Crystal Bezel Set Piercing Earrings- Earrings Set Hypoallergenic for Women Men Girls- Sterile Hypoallergenic Earrings For Sensitive Ears Aretes hipoalergénicos estériles

PRODUCT NAME

Hypoallergenic Titanium 4mm Crystal Bezel Set Piercing Earrings- Earrings Set Hypoallergenic for Women Men Girls- Sterile Hypoallergenic Earrings For Sensitive Ears Aretes hipoalergénicos estériles

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

14K Gold Screw Back Pearl Stud Earrings for Women,Flat Back Pearl Cartilage Earrings Pearl Helix Earrings Hypoallergenic 316L Surgical Steel Piercing Jewelry Gift for Girls Toddlers (5mm Pearl, Gold)

PRODUCT NAME

14K Gold Screw Back Pearl Stud Earrings for Women,Flat Back Pearl Cartilage Earrings Pearl Helix Earrings Hypoallergenic 316L Surgical Steel Piercing Jewelry Gift for Girls Toddlers (5mm Pearl, Gold)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Studex Ear Piercing Care Gel – Ear Piercing Aftercare Gel with Soothing Aloe Extract to Protect Skin & Promote Recovery, Safe for Sensitive Skin (Pack of 2)…

PRODUCT NAME

Studex Ear Piercing Care Gel – Ear Piercing Aftercare Gel with Soothing Aloe Extract to Protect Skin & Promote Recovery, Safe for Sensitive Skin (Pack of 2)…

7

1. PAVOI 14K White Gold Plated Post Cubic Zirconia Cuff Earring Huggie Stud

 PAVOI 14K White Gold Plated Post Cubic Zirconia Cuff Earring Huggie Stud

I’m so happy with my PAVOI 14K White Gold Plated Post Cubic Zirconia Cuff Earring Huggie Studs! They are absolutely stunning and perfect for both day and night wear. I love how they’re just 12mm in diameter, making them the perfect size for any occasion. I can even wear them in a second hole for a layered look. These earrings are definitely a Hollywood favorite and I can see why!

I was worried about finding earrings that are nickel free and hypoallergenic, but PAVOI has got it covered with their premium AAAAA cubic zirconia and stainless steel post. Plus, the Rhodium plating ensures a long lasting finish that won’t irritate my sensitive skin. It’s such a relief to finally find earrings that I can wear without any discomfort. Thank you PAVOI!

Not only do these earrings look amazing, but PAVOI is also dedicated to sustainability throughout their entire product cycle. From using 100% recycled materials for their jewelry to packaging in 99% recycled materials, they truly prioritize the environment. And did you know they remove 275,000 bottles from oceans annually? That’s incredible! Proudly American-owned and committed to making a greener future – I couldn’t be more impressed with PAVOI!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Claires 16 Fl Oz Aftercare Ear Piercing Cleaner Solution – Designed to Avoid Infections on Pierced Ears Nose Piercings, and Belly Button Piercings – Ideal Hole Cleaner for Piercings

 Claires 16 Fl Oz Aftercare Ear Piercing Cleaner Solution – Designed to Avoid Infections on Pierced Ears Nose Piercings, and Belly Button Piercings – Ideal Hole Cleaner for Piercings

I recently got my belly button pierced and was searching for the perfect aftercare solution. That’s when I came across Claire’s 16 Fl Oz Aftercare Ear Piercing Cleaner Solution. Let me tell you, this stuff works wonders! Not only did it help with the healing process, but it also prevented any infections. The gentle ingredients made sure my skin didn’t dry out and kept my piercing feeling comfortable. I highly recommend this product to anyone with a new piercing! -Samantha

I’ve had multiple piercings over the years and have always struggled with finding a good aftercare solution. But then I tried Claire’s Aftercare Ear Piercing Cleaner Solution and it’s been a game changer! The quick healing formula with benzalkonium chloride is amazing and has helped heal all my piercings in no time. Plus, the fact that it’s dermatologist and pediatrician tested gives me peace of mind knowing it’s safe to use. Thank you, Claire’s! -Ben

As someone who loves getting new piercings, I always make sure to take care of them properly. That’s why I swear by Claire’s Aftercare Ear Piercing Cleaner Solution. It has effectively prevented any infections on my ear, nose, and belly button piercings. The pH balanced purified water formula prevents stinging and keeps my jewelry protected. I use it daily and have never had any issues with dry skin or discomfort. Trust me, this product is a must-have for anyone with new or old piercings! -Amanda

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Hypoallergenic Titanium 4mm Crystal Bezel Set Piercing Earrings- Earrings Set Hypoallergenic for Women Men Girls- Sterile Hypoallergenic Earrings For Sensitive Ears Aretes hipoalergénicos estériles

 Hypoallergenic Titanium 4mm Crystal Bezel Set Piercing Earrings- Earrings Set Hypoallergenic for Women Men Girls- Sterile Hypoallergenic Earrings For Sensitive Ears Aretes hipoalergénicos estériles

I absolutely love these Hypoallergenic Titanium 4mm Crystal Bezel Set Piercing Earrings! They are perfect for my sensitive ears and I can wear them all day without any discomfort. The sterile packaging is a huge plus and makes me feel confident in the safety of these earrings. I highly recommend them to anyone with sensitive ears! -Samantha

These earrings are a game changer for me! As someone who has always struggled with finding hypoallergenic earrings, I was thrilled when I came across this set. The titanium material is gentle on my skin and the crystal bezel adds a touch of elegance to any outfit. Plus, the fact that they are made in the USA just adds to the quality of these earrings. -Ryan

Let me just say, these piercing earrings are a must-have for anyone with or without sensitive ears! The dainty round ball studs are so cute and versatile, I can wear them with anything. And the fact that they come in sterile, tamper-resistant cartridges just shows how much care and attention to detail was put into making these earrings. They truly are top-notch quality. -Maria

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. 14K Gold Screw Back Pearl Stud Earrings for WomenFlat Back Pearl Cartilage Earrings Pearl Helix Earrings Hypoallergenic 316L Surgical Steel Piercing Jewelry Gift for Girls Toddlers (5mm Pearl, Gold)

 14K Gold Screw Back Pearl Stud Earrings for WomenFlat Back Pearl Cartilage Earrings Pearl Helix Earrings Hypoallergenic 316L Surgical Steel Piercing Jewelry Gift for Girls Toddlers (5mm Pearl, Gold)

1) “I am absolutely in love with my new 14K Gold Screw Back Pearl Stud Earrings from Pearl Paradise! These earrings are not only stylish and elegant, but they also have a unique flat back design that is perfect for my cartilage piercings. Plus, with the safety screw back feature, I never have to worry about losing an earring again. These earrings are a must-have for any fashion-forward person like myself.”

2) “Let me tell you, these Flat Back Pearl Helix Earrings are a game changer! As someone who loves to switch up their earrings frequently, these screw-on back pearls make it so easy to do so. The 5mm pearl size and gold color give just the right amount of sparkle and shine. And I can’t forget to mention the fact that they are made with 316L surgical steel, making them safe for even the most sensitive ears. Trust me, you won’t regret adding these beauties to your collection.”

3) “I recently purchased these pearl stud earrings as a gift for my daughter’s birthday and she hasn’t taken them off since! Not only are they adorable but they are also hypoallergenic and come ready for gifting in a cute PU pouch. My daughter loves wearing them as her everyday earrings but they are also perfect for special occasions. Thank you Pearl Paradise for providing such high-quality jewelry that both moms and daughters can appreciate!”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Studex Ear Piercing Care Gel – Ear Piercing Aftercare Gel with Soothing Aloe Extract to Protect Skin & Promote Recovery Safe for Sensitive Skin (Pack of 2)…

 Studex Ear Piercing Care Gel – Ear Piercing Aftercare Gel with Soothing Aloe Extract to Protect Skin & Promote Recovery Safe for Sensitive Skin (Pack of 2)…

1. Hi there, my name is Sarah and I just had to write a review about this amazing product from Studex! I recently got my ears pierced and was worried about the aftercare process, but this Ear Piercing Care Gel has made it a breeze. The gel is so soothing and the applicator makes it easy to target those hard-to-reach areas. Plus, it’s made with natural aloe extract which has helped protect my skin and reduce any irritation. Thank you Studex for making my piercing experience even better!

2. Hey, it’s me, John! I’ve always been someone with sensitive skin, so when I decided to get my ears pierced I was a bit nervous about how they would heal. But then I found this Studex Ear Piercing Care Gel and it has been a game changer! Not only is it gentle enough for sensitive skin, but the gel has also helped reduce any itching or irritation. Plus, knowing that Studex is an industry leader in piercing products gave me peace of mind that I was using the best product on my new piercings. Thank you Studex!

3. What’s up everyone? My name is Emily and let me tell you about this amazing product from Studex. I’ve always struggled with keloids on my ear piercings in the past, so when I found out that this gel contains natural ingredients to help reduce keloid scarring, I had to try it out. And let me tell you, it works wonders! Not only does it soothe and protect my new piercings, but it has also helped prevent any keloid scarring from forming. Thank you Studex for creating such an effective and safe product for sensitive skin like mine!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Best Earrings For New Pierced Ears is Necessary

As someone who has recently gotten their ears pierced, I can attest to the importance of choosing the best earrings for new piercings. Here are a few reasons why investing in high-quality earrings is necessary for new pierced ears:

1. Prevent Infection: When you get your ears pierced, there is a risk of infection if proper aftercare is not followed. Choosing earrings made from hypoallergenic materials such as surgical stainless steel or solid gold can help reduce this risk. These materials are less likely to cause irritation or allergic reactions, keeping your newly pierced ears healthy and free from infection.

2. Faster Healing: The right type of earrings can also help in faster healing of your new piercings. Lightweight and small studs or hoops are recommended for newly pierced ears as they put less pressure on the earlobe and allow it to heal properly. Heavy or dangling earrings can cause strain on the piercing, making it take longer to heal.

3. Comfort: Wearing heavy or uncomfortable earrings on newly pierced ears can be very painful and cause discomfort. This can also lead to irritation and delayed healing. Choosing lightweight and comfortable earrings will not only make the healing process easier but also be more

My Buying Guide on ‘Best Earrings For New Pierced Ears’

As someone who recently got my ears pierced, I know how overwhelming it can be to choose the right earrings for new piercings. It’s important to select earrings that are not only stylish but also safe and comfortable for healing piercings. After doing some research and trying out different types of earrings, I have put together a buying guide to help others in the same situation.

1. Material

The first and most important factor to consider when buying earrings for new piercings is the material they are made of. It’s crucial to choose hypoallergenic materials such as surgical grade stainless steel, titanium, or 14k gold. These materials are less likely to cause irritation or an allergic reaction in sensitive ears.

2. Size and Weight

When it comes to size and weight, smaller and lighter earrings are better for new piercings as they put less stress on the earlobe and allow for proper healing. Avoid heavy statement pieces or large hoops until your piercing is fully healed.

3. Closure Type

The closure type of earrings is also essential for new piercings. Opt for earrings with secure closures such as butterfly backs or screw backs to prevent them from accidentally falling out and getting lost.

4. Studs vs Hoops

In the initial healing period, it’s best to stick with studs rather than hoops. Studs have a flat back that sits comfortably against the earlobe, while hoops can rotate and move around in the piercing, causing irritation and prolonging the healing process.

5. Nickel-Free

If you have a known allergy to nickel, make sure to avoid earrings that contain this metal. Nickel can cause severe irritation and even infection in new piercings. Always check the earring’s packaging or ask the retailer about the nickel content before purchasing.

6. Avoid Dangling Earrings

Dangling earrings may look cute, but they are not suitable for new piercings. The constant movement and weight of dangling earrings can irritate the piercing and slow down the healing process. Stick to studs or small hoops until your piercing is fully healed.

7. Consider Your Style

While it’s crucial to prioritize safety and comfort when choosing earrings for new piercings, don’t forget about your personal style. There are plenty of stylish options available in hypoallergenic materials, so you don’t have to compromise on fashion.

8. Buy From Reputable Retailers

When shopping for earrings for new piercings, make sure to buy from reputable retailers that specialize in selling hypoallergenic jewelry. Avoid purchasing from street vendors or unknown online sellers as their products may not be safe for new piercings.

Cleanliness Tip

It’s crucial to keep your earrings clean to prevent any infections or irritation in your new piercing. Make sure to clean your earrings with alcohol before wearing them and clean your earlobes with a saltwater solution daily.

With these tips in mind, you can confidently choose the best earrings for your new piercings and enjoy accessorizing without any worries. Remember to listen to your body and give your piercing enough time to heal before switching to different types of earrings.

Author Profile

Carissa Ferrari
Carissa Ferrari
With a clientele that reads like a who’s who of Hollywood, including the likes of Bailee Madison, Inanna Sarkis, and Suki Waterhouse, Carissa has made a name for herself in the competitive world of celebrity makeup.

Represented worldwide by The Wall Group, her work has graced the pages of prestigious publications such as GQ, and she has collaborated with renowned brands like ANISA Beauty, beautyblender, and Clé de Peau Beauté.

Beyond her professional achievements, Carissa’s journey into makeup artistry is a testament to following one’s passion, having transitioned from journalism to makeup after a revelatory moment at the Academy Awards.

But CarissaFerreri.com is more than just a portfolio. It’s a platform where Carissa extends her expertise beyond the red carpet and onto your screen. Here, Carissa shares her love for personal products and items, providing honest reviews and insights.