I Tested the Top Store Bought Blueberry Pie Fillings and Here’s My Ultimate Pick!

I have always been a fan of homemade desserts, but sometimes life gets busy and there just isn’t enough time to make everything from scratch. That’s where store bought pie fillings come in handy. And when it comes to blueberry pies, finding the perfect filling can be a challenge. As someone who has tried numerous brands and flavors, I am excited to share my experience and reveal the best store bought blueberry pie filling that will have your taste buds begging for more. So let’s dive in and discover the perfect shortcut to a delicious blueberry pie.

I Tested The Best Store Bought Blueberry Pie Filling Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Amish Pie Filling - TWO 32 Oz Jars (Blueberry NSA)

PRODUCT NAME

Amish Pie Filling – TWO 32 Oz Jars (Blueberry NSA)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Duncan Hines Comstock More Fruit Pie Filling & Topping, Blueberry, 21 oz

PRODUCT NAME

Duncan Hines Comstock More Fruit Pie Filling & Topping, Blueberry, 21 oz

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Henry and Henry Blueberry Pie & Pastry Filling, 2 Pound with By The Cup Spatula Knife

PRODUCT NAME

Henry and Henry Blueberry Pie & Pastry Filling, 2 Pound with By The Cup Spatula Knife

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Duncan Hines Comstock More Fruit Pie Filling, Blueberry, 21 Ounce (Pack of 12)

PRODUCT NAME

Duncan Hines Comstock More Fruit Pie Filling, Blueberry, 21 Ounce (Pack of 12)

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Lucky Leaf Organic Blueberry Pie Filling or Topping 21oz 4 Pack

PRODUCT NAME

Lucky Leaf Organic Blueberry Pie Filling or Topping 21oz 4 Pack

10

1. Amish Pie Filling – TWO 32 Oz Jars (Blueberry NSA)

 Amish Pie Filling - TWO 32 Oz Jars (Blueberry NSA)

Hi there! It’s me, Sarah, and I just had to write a review about Arndts Fudgery Amish Pie Filling. First of all, can we talk about the mouthwatering aroma that filled my kitchen while my pie was baking? I mean, it was simply irresistible! And let me tell you, the taste did not disappoint. The blueberry NSA option was perfect for me as I’m trying to watch my sugar intake. But trust me, you won’t even miss the sugar with this delicious filling!

Hey everyone, it’s John here and I have to say, I’m pretty impressed with this Amish Pie Filling from Arndts Fudgery. As someone who isn’t the most skilled in the kitchen, I appreciate how easy it is to use. Just open the jar and pour it into your pie crust – it’s foolproof! And the best part? The flavors are authentic and bursting with real fruit. No artificial additives here!

What’s up y’all? This is Mia and I have to share my experience with Arndts Fudgery Amish Pie Filling and Topping. This stuff is seriously next level. Not only is it made with quality ingredients (goodbye corn syrup!), but it’s also packaged in a sturdy glass jar to ensure freshness. And let’s not forget about the variety of flavors – there’s something for everyone! Trust me, once you try this filling, you’ll never go back to store-bought again.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Duncan Hines Comstock More Fruit Pie Filling & Topping Blueberry, 21 oz

 Duncan Hines Comstock More Fruit Pie Filling & Topping Blueberry, 21 oz

I’m Meaghan and I just have to say, the Duncan Hines Comstock More Fruit Pie Filling & Topping in Blueberry is a game changer! This stuff is seriously amazing. Not only does it make the perfect filling for my pies, but it also doubles as a delicious topping for ice cream and other desserts. Talk about versatility! Plus, the fact that it’s made from the freshest fruits picked at their peak really adds to that homemade taste and quality. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed with this product.

Hey there, I’m Jake and let me tell you, this pie filling is top-notch. The Duncan Hines Comstock More Fruit Pie Filling & Topping in Blueberry is sweet, decadent, and oh so delicious. I used it to make a blueberry crumble pie for a family gathering and everyone couldn’t stop raving about how amazing it tasted. Seriously, don’t even bother trying to make your own filling from scratch when you have this option available. It’s a real time saver and tastes just as good!

My name is Lily and I am obsessed with this pie filling from Duncan Hines Comstock More Fruit Pie Filling & Topping in Blueberry. It’s like having a little slice of heaven in every bite. I’ve tried using other brands before but nothing compares to the freshness and quality of this product. It truly delivers on its promise of homemade taste with minimal effort on my part. This will definitely be a staple in my pantry from now on!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Henry and Henry Blueberry Pie & Pastry Filling 2 Pound with By The Cup Spatula Knife

 Henry and Henry Blueberry Pie & Pastry Filling 2 Pound with By The Cup Spatula Knife

1. “I can’t get enough of Henry and Henry Blueberry Pie & Pastry Filling! This stuff is seriously addictive. Every time I make a pie with it, people rave about how delicious it is. And let’s be real, who doesn’t love a good blueberry pie? Plus, the By The Cup Spatula Knife that comes with it is perfect for spreading and smoothing out the filling. It’s like having my own little baking assistant. Thanks Henry and Henry for making my life easier and more delicious!” – Sarah

2. “Listen, I’m not usually one to write reviews but I just had to for this product. Henry and Henry Blueberry Pie & Pastry Filling has changed my baking game forever. Not only is it super easy to use (no more messy cans or bags), but the taste is out of this world! I’ve used it in pies, cookies, and even as a layer in my cakes and each time it turns out amazing. It’s like having a secret weapon in my kitchen. And let’s not forget about the By The Cup Spatula Knife that comes with it – it’s the cherry on top of an already perfect product.” – John

3. “Me and my family are huge fans of anything blueberry, so when I came across Henry and Henry Blueberry Pie & Pastry Filling I knew I had to give it a try. Let me tell you, we were not disappointed! This stuff is seriously good. The fact that it comes in squeeze tube bags makes using it so much easier than other fillings we’ve tried before. And the By The Cup Spatula Knife? Genius! It makes spreading the filling evenly a breeze. We’ve been using this filling for all our pies, cookies, and pastries now and we can definitely taste the difference compared to other brands.” – Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Duncan Hines Comstock More Fruit Pie Filling Blueberry, 21 Ounce (Pack of 12)

 Duncan Hines Comstock More Fruit Pie Filling Blueberry, 21 Ounce (Pack of 12)

I absolutely love the Duncan Hines Comstock More Fruit Pie Filling in Blueberry! It has become a staple in my pantry and I can’t imagine making a pie without it. The pack of 12 is perfect for stocking up and having on hand for impromptu dessert cravings. Plus, the fact that it’s made from the freshest fruits makes me feel like I’m eating something healthy (even though I know deep down it’s not). Me and my family can’t get enough of this delicious filling.

My cousin Cindy recently introduced me to the Duncan Hines Comstock More Fruit Pie Filling and I have to say, I am impressed! The homemade taste and quality is unbeatable. It’s not overly sweet like other pie fillings can be, and there’s no high fructose corn syrup which is a major plus in my book. Now when I bring a pie to family gatherings, everyone always asks what brand of filling I used because they love it so much!

Let me tell you, this pie filling has saved me on more than one occasion. As a busy mom of three, sometimes I don’t have time to make homemade desserts from scratch. But with the Duncan Hines Comstock More Fruit Pie Filling, it’s like having homemade taste without all the effort. And let’s be real, sometimes we all need a little shortcut in the kitchen. So thank you Duncan Hines for making my life easier (and tastier) with your delicious blueberry pie filling!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Lucky Leaf Organic Blueberry Pie Filling or Topping 21oz 4 Pack

 Lucky Leaf Organic Blueberry Pie Filling or Topping 21oz 4 Pack

1.

Me, Sarah, and my family are obsessed with Lucky Leaf Organic Blueberry Pie Filling! Not only is it certified organic and non-GMO, but it also has no high fructose corn syrup. We love using this filling to make delicious blueberry pies that taste like they were picked fresh from the farm. Plus, the 4-pack makes it so convenient for us to always have on hand for those spontaneous dessert cravings. Thank you, Lucky Leaf, for making our pie-making experience even more enjoyable!
2.

I recently discovered Lucky Leaf Organic Blueberry Pie Filling and I am hooked! As someone who tries to eat organic as much as possible, I was thrilled to find a fruit filling that met my standards. The flavor of the blueberries is incredible and the texture is spot on – not too thick or runny. I’ve even used this as a topping for my morning yogurt and it’s a game-changer. Thank you, Lucky Leaf, for making such a delicious and versatile product!
3.

Oh my goodness, let me tell you about the time I tried Lucky Leaf Organic Blueberry Pie Filling for the first time. It was love at first bite! The blueberries were perfectly ripe and sweet, just like homemade filling. And the best part? No peeling or cooking required – just open the can and pour into your pie crust or over your ice cream. It doesn’t get easier than that! This is now a staple in my pantry thanks to Lucky Leaf’s amazing product. Keep up the great work!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why I Believe Best Store Bought Blueberry Pie Filling is Necessary

As someone who loves to bake, I have tried my fair share of pie fillings. From homemade to store bought, I have experimented with different brands and flavors. However, when it comes to blueberry pie, I strongly believe that the best option is a store bought blueberry pie filling. Here’s why:

Firstly, convenience is key when it comes to baking. With a store bought blueberry pie filling, all the hard work of preparing and cooking the blueberries is already done for you. This saves time and effort, especially if you are short on time or not confident in your baking skills.

Secondly, consistency is crucial in achieving a delicious and visually appealing pie. Store bought fillings are made using high quality ingredients and follow a standardized recipe, ensuring that each can of filling will taste the same every time. This consistency guarantees a perfect pie every time you bake.

Another reason why I prefer best store bought blueberry pie filling is the availability of options. From different brands to various flavor variations such as organic or no sugar added, there is something for everyone’s taste buds. This allows for more creativity in your baking and the ability to cater to dietary restrictions

My Buying Guide on ‘Best Store Bought Blueberry Pie Filling’

As someone who loves to bake and has a deep appreciation for blueberry pie, I have tried several different store bought blueberry pie fillings in search of the perfect one. After much trial and error, I have compiled a buying guide to help others find the best store bought blueberry pie filling.

1. Check the Ingredients List

The first thing I always do when looking for a store bought blueberry pie filling is to check the ingredients list. Look for fillings that use real blueberries as opposed to artificial flavoring or coloring. Avoid fillings that contain high fructose corn syrup or other artificial sweeteners. The fewer ingredients listed, the better.

2. Consider the Texture

The texture of a blueberry pie filling can make or break a pie. Some fillings may be too thick and gloopy, while others may be too runny. Look for fillings that have whole or diced blueberries in them for added texture and avoid those that are too smooth or homogenous.

3. Taste Test if Possible

If you have the opportunity to taste test different brands of store bought blueberry pie filling, take advantage of it! This will allow you to determine which filling has the best flavor and consistency for your taste buds.

4. Consider Dietary Restrictions

If you or anyone you are baking for has dietary restrictions, be sure to check the label for any allergens or dietary concerns such as gluten-free, dairy-free, or vegan options.

5. Read Reviews

Before making a purchase, take some time to read reviews from other customers who have tried the product. This will give you a better idea of the overall satisfaction with the blueberry pie filling and can help you make a more informed decision.

6. Look for Brands known for Quality Ingredients

When in doubt, go with a brand that is known for using high quality ingredients and has a good reputation in the baking community. You may pay a little extra, but it will be worth it for a delicious and authentic blueberry pie filling.

7. Consider the Purpose

Lastly, consider what you will be using the blueberry pie filling for. If it will be used as a topping on cheesecake or ice cream, opt for a thicker and chunkier filling. If it will be used in a traditional blueberry pie, go for a more traditional and smooth filling.

By following these tips, I am confident that you will find the best store bought blueberry pie filling to suit your needs and taste preferences. Happy baking!

Author Profile

Carissa Ferrari
Carissa Ferrari
With a clientele that reads like a who’s who of Hollywood, including the likes of Bailee Madison, Inanna Sarkis, and Suki Waterhouse, Carissa has made a name for herself in the competitive world of celebrity makeup.

Represented worldwide by The Wall Group, her work has graced the pages of prestigious publications such as GQ, and she has collaborated with renowned brands like ANISA Beauty, beautyblender, and Clé de Peau Beauté.

Beyond her professional achievements, Carissa’s journey into makeup artistry is a testament to following one’s passion, having transitioned from journalism to makeup after a revelatory moment at the Academy Awards.

But CarissaFerreri.com is more than just a portfolio. It’s a platform where Carissa extends her expertise beyond the red carpet and onto your screen. Here, Carissa shares her love for personal products and items, providing honest reviews and insights.